Video: Shocking Water Filter Review & Comparison


Do you own any of these systems? If you own anything other than a Berkey system, it might be featured here in this video by LDSPrepper. He has over 150 videos and has tons of subscribers on his YouTube channel. If you get a chance, visit his channel and subscribe to it. We recently heard this video review and appreciate the things he had to say. Check out the video:

20 Responses to Video: Shocking Water Filter Review & Comparison

  1. John July 7, 2012 at 11:49 am #

    Very interesting. Good review and comparison.

  2. Marksman July 9, 2012 at 5:27 am #

    Your review is excellent, well researched and well presented. I love my Berkey systems – just like yours but I bought the plastic tubs for the 3 gallon system and a stainless steel 1 gallon system for the office. Also the portable filters are constantly in my vehicles in case of emergency. Thanks for your efforts and sharing your results. I just hope some people will wake up and get their filters before it is too late.

    • David July 9, 2012 at 6:11 am #

      Thanks for the kind comments, Marksman!

  3. Marjorie Jones July 9, 2012 at 7:12 pm #

    Hi Berkey Guy.

    I am not a happy camper. I am on my second set of filters and have performed the red dye test and my water is beet red. The first ones were defective and these are the replacements. I don’t know whether to try for a third set… I will call the Western Distributions Center tomorrow and ask. But it doesn’t say much for your prized Berkey brand.

    I have the stainless steel model, and am using both the regular filters and the fluoride ones. I had only the regular black ones replaced, but I’m not sure which ones are not filtering the red dye.

    Any suggestions?

    • David July 9, 2012 at 8:35 pm #

      Thank you for your comment Marjorie. Many people think that the filters are defective but often times the wingnuts are not fastened snug enough to create a seal. In these cases, the red water circumvents the black washer and wingnut to give a false positive result. Also, it is recommended that you remove the PF2 Fluoride & Arsenic Reduction Elements when testing the black filters.

      We maintain full confidence in our relationship with and purchases from New Millennium Concepts, Ltd. which manufactures the Berkey products. Every business has challenges on its path to growth and our endorsement of this product continues forward.

      In the event that the filters are not working properly, with everything assembled correctly, please call us at tomorrow at 877-886-3653. We’ll be happy to talk with you on the phone and get you in contact with the manufacturer New Millennium Concepts if necessary. They will be able to help you with a warranty claim if that proves necessary. As of August 2011, the Black Berkey Element design was improved upon to prevent defects in workmanship.

      Thanks & we look forward to hearing from you and helping you,

    • Darren July 9, 2012 at 11:57 pm #

      U could be piercing the filters by over tightening the screws?

  4. Jerry Cook July 10, 2012 at 5:40 am #

    I bought a big berkey because my water has a lot of chlorine in it. The filter totally handles the problem. Just wonder why they don’t advertise on infowars anymore

  5. Marjorie Jones July 10, 2012 at 4:05 pm #

    Hey David!

    Yeaaaah! I tried it again… put the washers both on the inside of the top tank, between the filter and the tank bottom… and another set on the screw-tubes that poke through into the bottom tank. Four washers all told. Then I put cups inside the bottom tank below the two filters and dumped in the red dye and so far the water dripping into the little cups is clear!!! Can’t wait to taste it! Thanks for all your helpful suggestions. Don’t think I’m going to need to return these babies.

    • David July 10, 2012 at 4:21 pm #

      Thanks for calling us and we’re happy that our conversation helped you out!


  6. Marjorie Jones July 10, 2012 at 7:32 pm #

    Ooops! Not so fast! It’s pink again.

    I’m just reporting this for the benefit of others. I did my first red dye test while leaving the fluoride filters still attached. When I did it a second time, after attaching the black filters correctly, the water came through clear, but I had taken the fluoride filters off.

    So, when I put the fluoride filters back on, the water then became pink again. I’m sure it is from the fluoride filters having picked up the dye, like you said, David, and I will just let it run through a few times and hope it goes away. I expect the water is safe to drink as it’s only food coloring I used.

    Just keeping you in the loop,… others might have wondered how my sloppy experiments turned out.

    • David July 11, 2012 at 7:48 am #

      Unfortunately, I don’t know any remedy for getting the red food coloring out of the PF2s. We have had one other customer call us and experience the same thing, only her PF2s would not lose the red food coloring. It might be best for us to get you in direct contact with New Millennium, perhaps they might have a tip to help out. As always, please feel free to call us and we’ll do what we can to help you.


    • karen August 30, 2016 at 8:07 am #

      Marjorie- I made the same mistake WOOPS – I finally got my working black filters but because I left the flou
      ride on with the first red dye test it did go through & now I have new black filter (only one was defective -banged in mail I suspect) and they filter the red dye perfectly but I still have some red dye stuck in one of my fluoride filters haha woops! But I do know the water is safe & that was due to my mistake lol – ugh haha but am excited as I have wanted a berkey for a year now!

  7. Marjorie Jones July 10, 2012 at 7:34 pm #

    One more thing … I also primed both the black filters and the fluoride filters again before trying it a second time. So I hope I got most of the red out of the fluoride ones, but it’s still pink, so we shall see.

  8. Alan July 16, 2012 at 1:07 pm #

    Before New Millennium recently changed the design of the plastic base on the black elements, I use to have A TON of problems with the adhesive seal coming undone when I primed them. It got to the point where I just stopped priming them, but it was just a matter of time before water would seep underneath the filter and into the bottom tank. Fortunately, they have reinforced the plastic base and I have not had a problem since!

    • David July 16, 2012 at 1:11 pm #

      Thank you for your feedback Alan! We appreciate your input.


  9. wyocowboy July 22, 2012 at 10:28 am #

    Hi I have used a set of black filters for what seams like forever. When the water coming threw the filters starts slowing down I just was them off under the facet and they work very well again. I guess I need to use the food coloring test to see how they are filtering. Use potable watter so not to worried about it. Just read about the food coloring test so will try it when I get home in a couple of months. GOOD VID

    • David July 25, 2012 at 10:04 am #

      Thanks for the comment WyoCowboy!


  10. Water Purifiers July 31, 2012 at 5:40 pm #

    I thought this video was great and has helped me make my decision on buying a berkey system. Thanks

  11. christy September 11, 2012 at 7:48 pm #

    We have been saving up to add a Berkey system to our emergency kit for awhile. After doing our research and reading reviews, it’s the only system we want.

Leave a Reply